Monday, February 18, 2008

ALL MY NAMES KNOW YOUR LEAP: SURREALIST WOMEN & THEIR CHALLENGE


Exerpts from the Introduction to Surrealist Women: An International Anthology
Edited with Introductions by Penelope Rosemont
Austin: University of Texas Press, 1998

"Knock hard. Life is deaf." —Mimi Parent

Although the first women of surrealism have been almost entirely overlooked in the historical and critical literature, clearly they were a bold, imaginative, and in many other ways a remarkable lot. Even before surrealism's first Manifesto appeared in Paris in 1924, women were active in the movement, and they have been expanding and illuminating its universe ever since. In all the arts and major genres of writing, women helped develop surrealism's radical poetic/critical outlook, and thus helped make it what it was and is. To ignore their contributions is to ignore some of the best of surrealism.

This book seeks to bring to light as much as possible the quality, range, diversity and vitality of women participants in the international Surrealist Movement. Although the contributions of women have been acknowledged and in some cases celebrated within the movement itself, they are hardly known outside it. In the U.S., the few books devoted to the topic of women and surrealism are narrowly concerned with a dozen or so "stars"—mostly painters and photographers whose work has finally, and most often posthumously, attained some standing in the art market. As a result, women surrealists whose principal vehicle of expression is the written word have been especially neglected. This neglect, in turn, has maintained old stereotypes and other misapprehensions of the surrealist project. Generalizations about surrealism based entirely on painters are bound to be misleading, because surrealism never has been primarily a movement of painters. Indeed, if the evidence of surrealism's numerous women poets and thinkers has been suppressed, how could the prevailing conceptions of surrealism be anything but false?

I hope that this gathering of poems, automatic texts, dreams, tales, theoretical articles, declarations, polemics, games and responses to inquiries will help correct this distortion by revealing some of the many ways in which women have enriched surrealism as a ferment of ideas, an imaginative stimulus, a liberating critical force, and a practical inspiration to poetic, moral and political insurgency.


* * *

Unlike most twentieth-century cultural and political currents, the surrealist movement has always opposed overt as well as de facto segregation along racial, ethnic or gender lines. From the very first issue of La Révolution surréaliste, writings by women appeared alongside those of their male comrades. Works by women artists were regularly included in surrealist exhibitions. As one perceptive commentator (Robert Short) has pointed out, "No comparable movement outside specifically feminist organizations has had such a high proportion of active women participants."

Moreover, until very recently, most of the literature on women surrealists was written by other surrealists, male and female. If these women remain little known to the larger reading public it is because critics and scholars have been shirking their responsibilities.


* * *

The fact is, apart from the rare anthologies issued by the surrealists themselves, women have almost always been left out. Well over two-thirds of the women included here have never been represented in any anthology; many of these writings have never been reprinted since their original publication. In all but a few of the hundreds of works on surrealism in English, women surrealists are barely even mentioned. The exclusion of women from the existing compilations warrants —indeed, compels, if only for the sake of historical accuracy—an attempt to restore balance by emphasizing what so many others have denied.

It is essential, moreover, that the recovery of surrealism's lost voices not do violence to the ideas and inspirations that motivated them. Unfortunately, the few books that do acknowledge, to some extent, women's activity in surrealism, tend to be less than scrupulous in their accounts of surrealism as a body of thought and an organized movement. My intention in putting together this mass of heretofore inaccessible material has not been to project fashionable new theories, much less to subject the recent literature on surrealism to a detailed critique, but simply to try to learn what the many women involved in surrealism have had to say for themselves.

What is different about this anthology is that here, for the first time, an unprecedentedly large number of surrealist women are allowed to speak in their own voices, and in a specifically surrealist context—which is, after all, the context they freely chose for themselves. This anthology is thus the opposite of isolationist, for its guiding purpose is rather one of reintegration. By making these writings available at last, I hope to make it impossible—or at least inexcusable—for students of surrealism to continue to ignore them. I want first of all to call attention to an impressive number of important surrealist writers who for various reasons have not received the attention they deserve. The fact that they happen to be women helps explain why they have been ignored outside the movement, just as it also affects what surrealism has meant to them. I try to show not only what they took from surrealism but also what they gave to it; how they used it for their own purposes, developed it, played with it, strengthened it, endowing it with a universality it could not have attained without them.


* * *

The achievements of surrealism's women writers, and the challenges they pose, were and are important, not only for the Surrealist Movement, but for all genuine seekers of knowledge, inspiration and a better world. It is striking how contemporary so many of these writings are—how much they anticipate present-day radical and cultural preoccupations, how often texts written thirty, forty or sixty-five years ago seem to go beyond the limits of current debates. Nancy Cunard, for example, unlike many who consider themselves anti-racists today, fearlessly acknowledged the revolutionary implications of the critique of "whiteness"; far from being merely academic or aesthetic, her passion for African art and African American jazz was inseparable from her practical support to the world movement for Black Liberation. Similarly, the "gender-bending" texts in these pages convey the message that true sexual freedom cannot be attained in a society mired in what Marx called the "fetishism of commodities." And it is impossible to overlook the radical ecological sensibility that runs through this book like a pack of wolves. Ecological concerns engaged the surrealist movement as a whole almost from the start; in surrealism, the adjective wild has always been a term of the highest prestige. But it is primarily the women in surrealism who stressed these matters, and they who deserve credit for making the ecological critique an integral part of the surrealist project.

Nature, wildlife, wilderness are constant, compelling themes in the work of surrealist women. Redefinition of the relation between humankind and other animals, solidarity with endangered species, a non-exploitative regard for the planet we live on: These are some of the dreams whose realization they call for. In their poetry and other writings, as well as in the plastic arts, dance and film, we see the natural world in myriad new lights. Time and again in the texts that follow, surrealist women voice the latent yearnings of a planet on the verge of disaster. Agar, Carrington, Césaire, Johnson, Mitrani, Low, Oppenheim, Rahon, Senard and many others are not only manifest forerunners of deep ecology and ecofeminism, but could even be considered exponents of these currents, decades before either had a name. As surrealists, of course, they avoided the "New Age" techno-mysticism and other ideological fads—not to mention racism—that mars so much mainstream feminist and ecological literature today. What is most important is that these women found that surrealism itself embraces feminist as well as ecological concerns. Always implicit in surrealist thought, a radical ecological awareness is increasingly explicit in movement publications after 1945.

Meret Oppenheim identified the key methodological principle here when she pointed out in 1955 that works produced via psychic automatism "will always remain alive and will always be revolutionary . . . because they are in organic liaison with Nature." This is the very basis of surrealism as a revolutionary community: the unity of theory and practice at the highest point of tension of individual and collective creation.

Such a conception of life and the world, defined by audacity and readiness for change, is the opposite of all the dominant ideologies of our time. In these pages you will find no "postmodern" complacency, no apology for human misery, no blasé hopelessness in the face of cataclysm, no confidence in lesser evils, no scorn for utopia, no cynicism. All here is urgency and expectation, and the conviction that a poetics of revolt is the only way that might—just might—lead us all to something at least a little closer to earthly paradise.

By emphasizing the ecological dimension of revolutionary social transformation, women surrealists gave the surrealist notion of a non-repressive civilization a far more concrete actuality than it had before. Not only did they perceive the links between the emancipation of women, of the working class, of all humankind and of Nature—they also comprehended that all these emancipations are in reality but one. "Here at last," wrote Suzanne Césaire in 1941, referring to the domain of the Marvelous, "the world of nature and things makes direct contact with the human being who is again in the fullest sense spontaneous and natural. Here at last is the true communion and the true knowledge, chance mastered and recognized, the mystery now a friend, and helpful." In the heat of such inspirations, poetic insight points the way to a life worth living. Suzanne Césaire and other women in the movement deserve a large share of the credit for surrealism's becoming in effect a new universal, in the Hegelian sense: a realizable global vision of marvelous freedom for all.

The women's movement has never demanded too much; too often, alas, it has settled for much too little, too late. In no society on Earth are women fully equal; there is not one in which any of us, woman or man, is truly free. Many of the early surrealist slogans—such as "Open the Prisons!" and "Disband the Army!"—seem to me to be just what the women's movement needs today. And beyond all slogans, isn't it obvious that nothing less than our wildest dreams will enable women to rise from the depressing military-industrial depths of the current political impasse?

Penelope Rosemont

Chicago, January 1997

The above copied from: http://www.surrealistmovement-usa.org/pages/swallmy.html

Surrealist Women: An International Anthology is available from the University of Texas Press:
http://www.utexas.edu/utpress/books/rossur.html

ANDRÉ BRETON, from The Second Manifesto of Surrealism, 1930

Everything tends to make us believe that there exists a certain point of the mind at which life and death, the real and the imagined, past and future, the communicable and the incommunicable, high and low, cease to be perceived as contradictions. Now, search as one may one will never find any other motivating force in the activities of the Surrealists than the hope of finding and fixing this point. From this it becomes obvious how absurd it would be to define Surrealism solely as constructive or destructive: the point to which we are referring is a fortiori that point where construction and destruction can no longer be brandished one against the other. It is also clear that Surrealism is not interested in giving very serious consideration to anything that happens outside of itself, under the guise of art, or even anti-art, of philosophy or anti-philosophy — in short, at anything not aimed at the annihilation of the being into a diamond, all blind and interior, which is no more the soul of ice than that of fire.

. . . The simplest Surrealist act consists of dashing down the street, pistol in hand, and firing blindly, as fast as you can pull the trigger, into the crowd. Anyone who, at least once in his life, has not dreamed of thus putting an end to the petty system of debasement and cretinization in effect has a well-defined place in that crowd, with his belly at barrel level . . .

. . . let us not lose sight of the fact that the idea of surrealism aims quite simply at the total recovery of our psychic force by a means which is nothing other than the dizzying descent into ourselves, the systematic illumination of hidden places and the progressive darkening of other places, the perpetual excursion into the midst of forbidden territory . . .

The above copied from:
http://pers-www.wlv.ac.uk/~fa1871/surrext.html

Manifesto of Surrealism



BY ANDRÉ BRETON (1924)

So strong is the belief in life, in what is most fragile in life – real life, I mean – that in the end this belief is lost. Man, that inveterate dreamer, daily more discontent with his destiny, has trouble assessing the objects he has been led to use, objects that his nonchalance has brought his way, or that he has earned through his own efforts, almost always through his own efforts, for he has agreed to work, at least he has not refused to try his luck (or what he calls his luck!). At this point he feels extremely modest: he knows what women he has had, what silly affairs he has been involved in; he is unimpressed by his wealth or his poverty, in this respect he is still a newborn babe and, as for the approval of his conscience, I confess that he does very nicely without it. If he still retains a certain lucidity, all he can do is turn back toward his childhood which, however his guides and mentors may have botched it, still strikes him as somehow charming. There, the absence of any known restrictions allows him the perspective of several lives lived at once; this illusion becomes firmly rooted within him; now he is only interested in the fleeting, the extreme facility of everything. Children set off each day without a worry in the world. Everything is near at hand, the worst material conditions are fine. The woods are white or black, one will never sleep.

But it is true that we would not dare venture so far, it is not merely a question of distance. Threat is piled upon threat, one yields, abandons a portion of the terrain to be conquered. This imagination which knows no bounds is henceforth allowed to be exercised only in strict accordance with the laws of an arbitrary utility; it is incapable of assuming this inferior role for very long and, in the vicinity of the twentieth year, generally prefers to abandon man to his lusterless fate.

Though he may later try to pull himself together on occasion, having felt that he is losing by slow degrees all reason for living, incapable as he has become of being able to rise to some exceptional situation such as love, he will hardly succeed. This is because he henceforth belongs body and soul to an imperative practical necessity which demands his constant attention. None of his gestures will be expansive, none of his ideas generous or far-reaching. In his mind’s eye, events real or imagined will be seen only as they relate to a welter of similar events, events in which he has not participated, abortive events. What am I saying: he will judge them in relationship to one of these events whose consequences are more reassuring than the others. On no account will he view them as his salvation.

Beloved imagination, what I most like in you is your unsparing quality.

There remains madness, "the madness that one locks up," as it has aptly been described. That madness or another…. We all know, in fact, that the insane owe their incarceration to a tiny number of legally reprehensible acts and that, were it not for these acts their freedom (or what we see as their freedom) would not be threatened. I am willing to admit that they are, to some degree, victims of their imagination, in that it induces them not to pay attention to certain rules – outside of which the species feels threatened – which we are all supposed to know and respect. But their profound indifference to the way in which we judge them, and even to the various punishments meted out to them, allows us to suppose that they derive a great deal of comfort and consolation from their imagination, that they enjoy their madness sufficiently to endure the thought that its validity does not extend beyond themselves. And, indeed, hallucinations, illusions, etc., are not a source of trifling pleasure. The best controlled sensuality partakes of it, and I know that there are many evenings when I would gladly that pretty hand which, during the last pages of Taine’s L’Intelligence, indulges in some curious misdeeds. I could spend my whole life prying loose the secrets of the insane. These people are honest to a fault, and their naiveté has no peer but my own. Christopher Columbus should have set out to discover America with a boatload of madmen. And note how this madness has taken shape, and endured.



It is not the fear of madness which will oblige us to leave the flag of imagination furled.

The case against the realistic attitude demands to be examined, following the case against the materialistic attitude. The latter, more poetic in fact than the former, admittedly implies on the part of man a kind of monstrous pride which, admittedly, is monstrous, but not a new and more complete decay. It should above all be viewed as a welcome reaction against certain ridiculous tendencies of spiritualism. Finally, it is not incompatible with a certain nobility of thought.

By contrast, the realistic attitude, inspired by positivism, from Saint Thomas Aquinas to Anatole France, clearly seems to me to be hostile to any intellectual or moral advancement. I loathe it, for it is made up of mediocrity, hate, and dull conceit. It is this attitude which today gives birth to these ridiculous books, these insulting plays. It constantly feeds on and derives strength from the newspapers and stultifies both science and art by assiduously flattering the lowest of tastes; clarity bordering on stupidity, a dog’s life. The activity of the best minds feels the effects of it; the law of the lowest common denominator finally prevails upon them as it does upon the others. An amusing result of this state of affairs, in literature for example, is the generous supply of novels. Each person adds his personal little "observation" to the whole. As a cleansing antidote to all this, M. Paul Valéry recently suggested that an anthology be compiled in which the largest possible number of opening passages from novels be offered; the resulting insanity, he predicted, would be a source of considerable edification. The most famous authors would be included. Such a though reflects great credit on Paul Valéry who, some time ago, speaking of novels, assured me that, so far as he was concerned, he would continue to refrain from writing: "The Marquise went out at five." But has he kept his word?

If the purely informative style, of which the sentence just quoted is a prime example, is virtually the rule rather than the exception in the novel form, it is because, in all fairness, the author’s ambition is severely circumscribed. The circumstantial, needlessly specific nature of each of their notations leads me to believe that they are perpetrating a joke at my expense. I am spared not even one of the character’s slightest vacillations: will he be fairhaired? what will his name be? will we first meet him during the summer? So many questions resolved once and for all, as chance directs; the only discretionary power left me is to close the book, which I am careful to do somewhere in the vicinity of the first page. And the descriptions! There is nothing to which their vacuity can be compared; they are nothing but so many superimposed images taken from some stock catalogue, which the author utilizes more and more whenever he chooses; he seizes the opportunity to slip me his postcards, he tries to make me agree with him about the clichés:

The small room into which the young man was shown was covered with yellow wallpaper: there were geraniums in the windows, which were covered with muslin curtains; the setting sun cast a harsh light over the entire setting…. There was nothing special about the room. The furniture, of yellow wood, was all very old. A sofa with a tall back turned down, an oval table opposite the sofa, a dressing table and a mirror set against the pierglass, some chairs along the walls, two or three etchings of no value portraying some German girls with birds in their hands – such were the furnishings. (Dostoevski, Crime and Punishment)



I am in no mood to admit that the mind is interested in occupying itself with such matters, even fleetingly. It may be argued that this school-boy description has its place, and that at this juncture of the book the author has his reasons for burdening me. Nevertheless he is wasting his time, for I refuse to go into his room. Others’ laziness or fatigue does not interest me. I have too unstable a notion of the continuity of life to equate or compare my moments of depression or weakness with my best moments. When one ceases to feel, I am of the opinion one should keep quiet. And I would like it understood that I am not accusing or condemning lack of originality as such. I am only saying that I do not take particular note of the empty moments of my life, that it may be unworthy for any man to crystallize those which seem to him to be so. I shall, with your permission, ignore the description of that room, and many more like it.

Not so fast, there; I’m getting into the area of psychology, a subject about which I shall be careful not to joke.

The author attacks a character and, this being settled upon, parades his hero to and fro across the world. No matter what happens, this hero, whose actions and reactions are admirably predictable, is compelled not to thwart or upset -- even though he looks as though he is -- the calculations of which he is the object. The currents of life can appear to lift him up, roll him over, cast him down, he will still belong to this readymade human type. A simple game of chess which doesn't interest me in the least -- man, whoever he may be, being for me a mediocre opponent. What I cannot bear are those wretched discussions relative to such and such a move, since winning or losing is not in question. And if the game is not worth the candle, if objective reason does a frightful job -- as indeed it does -- of serving him who calls upon it, is it not fitting and proper to avoid all contact with these categories? "Diversity is so vast that every different tone of voice, every step, cough, every wipe of the nose, every sneeze...."* (Pascal.) If in a cluster of grapes there are no two alike, why do you want me to describe this grape by the other, by all the others, why do you want me to make a palatable grape? Our brains are dulled by the incurable mania of wanting to make the unknown known, classifiable. The desire for analysis wins out over the sentiments.** (Barrès, Proust.) The result is statements of undue length whose persuasive power is attributable solely to their strangeness and which impress the reader only by the abstract quality of their vocabulary, which moreover is ill-defined. If the general ideas that philosophy has thus far come up with as topics of discussion revealed by their very nature their definitive incursion into a broader or more general area. I would be the first to greet the news with joy. But up till now it has been nothing but idle repartee; the flashes of wit and other niceties vie in concealing from us the true thought in search of itself, instead of concentrating on obtaining successes. It seems to me that every act is its own justification, at least for the person who has been capable of committing it, that it is endowed with a radiant power which the slightest gloss is certain to diminish. Because of this gloss, it even in a sense ceases to happen. It gains nothing to be thus distinguished. Stendhal's heroes are subject to the comments and appraisals -- appraisals which are more or less successful -- made by that author, which add not one whit to their glory. Where we really find them again is at the point at which Stendahl has lost them.

(To read the next section of the Manifesto, go to: http://umintermediai501.blogspot.com/2007/12/first-surrealist-manifesto-andr-breton.html)

The above copied from:
http://www.screensite.org/courses/Jbutler/T340/SurManifesto/ManifestoOfSurrealism.htm

Secrets of the Magical Surrealist Art


Written Surrealist composition
or
first and last draft

by André Breton
(from Manifesto of Surrealism, 1924)

After you have settled yourself in a place as favorable as possible to the concentration of your mind upon itself, have writing materials brought to you. Put yourself in as passive, or receptive, a state of mind as you can. Forget about your genius, your talents, and the talents of everyone else. Keep reminding yourself that literature is one of the saddest roads that leads to everything. Write quickly, without any preconceived subject, fast enough so that you will not remember what you're writing and be tempted to reread what you have written. The first sentence will come spontaneously, so compelling is the truth that with every passing second there is a sentence unknown to our consciousness which is only crying out to be heard. It is somewhat of a problem to form an opinion about the next sentence; it doubtless partakes both of our conscious activity and of the other, if one agrees that the fact of having written the first entails a minimum of perception. This should be of no importance to you, however; to a large extent, this is what is most interesting and intriguing about the Surrealist game. The fact still remains that punctuation no doubt resists the absolute continuity of the flow with which we are concerned, although it may seem as necessary as the arrangement of knots in a vibrating cord. Go on as long as you like. Put your trust in the inexhaustible nature of the murmur. If silence threatens to settle in if you should ever happen to make a mistake -- a mistake, perhaps due to carelessness -- break off without hesitation with an overly clear line. Following a word the origin of which seems suspicious to you, place any letter whatsoever, the letter "l" for example, always the letter "l," and bring the arbitrary back by making this letter the first of the following word.

How not to be bored any longer when with others

This is very difficult. Don't be at home for anyone, and occasionally, when no one has forced his way in, interrupting you in the midst of your Surrealist activity, and you, crossing your arms, say: "It doesn't matter, there are doubtless better things to do or not do. Interest in life is indefensible Simplicity, what is going on inside me, is still tiresome to me!" or an other revolting banality.

To make speeches

Just prior to the elections, in the first country which deems it worthwhile to proceed in this kind of public expression of opinion, have yourself put on the ballot. Each of us has within himself the potential of an orator: multicolored loin cloths, glass trinkets of words. Through Surrealism he will take despair unawares in its poverty. One night, on a stage, he will, by himself, carve up the eternal heaven, that Peau de l'ours. He will promise so much that any promises he keeps will be a source of wonder and dismay. In answer to the claims of an entire people he will give a partial and ludicrous vote. He will make the bitterest enemies partake of a secret desire which will blow up the countries. And in this he will succeed simply by allowing himself to be moved by the immense word which dissolves into pity and revolves in hate. Incapable of failure, he will play on the velvet of all failures. He will be truly elected, and women will love him with an all-consuming passion.

To write false novels

Whoever you may be, if the spirit moves you burn a few laurel leaves and, without wishing to tend this meager fire, you will begin to write a novel. Surrealism will allow you to: all you have to do is set the needle marked "fair" at "action," and the rest will follow naturally. Here are some characters rather different in appearance; their names in your handwriting are a question of capital letters, and they will conduct themselves with the same ease with respect to active verbs as does the impersonal pronoun "it" with respect to words such as "is raining," "is," "must," etc. They will command them, so to speak, and wherever observation, reflection, and the faculty of generalization prove to be of no help to you, you may rest assured that they will credit you with a thousand intentions you never had. Thus endowed with a tiny number of physical and moral characteristics, these beings who in truth owe you so little will thereafter deviate not one iota from a certain line of conduct about which you need not concern yourself any further. Out of this will result a plot more or less clever in appearance, justifying point by point this moving or comforting denouement about which you couldn't care less. Your false novel will simulate to a marvelous degree a real novel; you will be rich, and everyone will agree that "you've really got a lot of guts," since it's also in this region that this something is located.

Of course, by an analogous method, and provided you ignore what you are reviewing, you can successfully devote yourself to false literary criticism.

Copied from:
http://www.screensite.org/courses/Jbutler/T340/SurManifesto/ManifestoOfSurrealism.htm

Sunday, February 17, 2008

Chaos, Art and the Age of Uncertainty, William Cleveland


(This speech was originally delivered on November 1, 1997 at the annual conference of the National Assembly of State Arts Agencies.)

Song
Darkness is a way of life
when you don't know the way.
When you find the way, darkness shatters
like an old glass bottle.
A ticket falls out
A ticket to a lifetime of love

I like singing for strangers. I like it because often, after the offering of a song, some of our strangeness has been nudged a little closer towards the familiar. And when the familiar is given some space what follows—what I have to share—maybe, has a chance of being heard with the same spirit of offering.

Another thing I like to do when I enter into unfamiliar territory, in a suit, on stage, facing a room full of other suits, in Cleveland in the Fall of 1997, is drag my friends along to keep me company. So, today, in keeping with that tradition, I'd like to introduce you to a couple of my closest friends.

My first friend, Aaron, is someone you've already been introduced to. Aaron has entered the Playhouse Theater and joined me here on stage through the words of the song I just shared. These words are his.

The ticket Aaron refers to in his song is the poetry and music and painting that came into his life during the two years he spent at a treatment community called FamiliesFirst. Now Aaron came to FamiliesFirst with a pretty rotten life under his belt. Severely abused as a youngster, he returned the favor by becoming an incredibly violent predator and self abuser by the age of nine. But by the time he was 11, after 2 years at FamiliesFirst, he had become a well adjusted young man, socially and in school and was able to say, in no uncertain terms, that art saved his life.

Aaron had the opportunity to write his poem because, in 1990 FamiliesFirst made a commitment to infuse the entire treatment community with the arts—top to bottom. They made this significant investment because they knew it helped kids like Aaron make sense of a confusing world. (a slide of a self-portrait by Aaron is presented)

This is Aaron's self-portrait. I think it is appropriate that we see him facing away, looking outward into the 21st century, maybe imagining a future that differs radically from his own unpredictable, out-of-balance past. I certainly hope so!

And you know Aaron's past is not unlike those of many of our communities who are also in search of a new kind of balance—a balance between the safe and the challenging, the material and the transcendent, tradition and modernity, opportunity and responsibility, chaos and order. A balanced future that does not repeat the sins that have been visited on the thousands of Aarons that are born into our communities every day.

My other friend is a little older. Actually he/she is your friend too, and has been for thousands of years. This of course is the Shaman—arguably the most important individual in the pre-historical community.

I don't know if many of you are aware that recent archeological excavations have unearthed a new treasure-trove of ancient writings. Among these writings are the job descriptions of various leaders in pre-historical community life. Here are the job specs for Shaman 4 (exempt).

Shaman 4

Reporting to the various gods and spirits, this position is responsible for building and maintaining the ritual fire, healing the sick, maintaining and teaching of tribal history, rituals and celebrations, educating and preparing youth for adulthood, the preparation and delivery of all rites of passage: including birth, marriage, death and all activities related to the fertility of our fields and families and other duties as required. Candidates should have relevant and extensive experience as a dancer, poet, painter, drummer, singer, storyteller, healer, mediator, teacher,—and a working knowledge of spiritual mechanics. The successful candidate will represent the community in its practical relationship with the gods and preside over the most important activities in our community.

This shaman, of course, is our direct descendent. This is the pre-art artist.

Now why have I invited these two friends to share the stage with me?

I brought Aaron because I'd like you to keep Aaron in mind during the rest of my talk. Not because I think all of you are going to personally end up running programs for severely mentally disturbed pre-adolescents, but because Aaron's presence through his song is a good reminder of the potential power of our work and the level of responsibility with which that power needs to be handled.

I always bring the Shaman along to remind myself of our long and significant history as community builders. And as a marker to gauge how truly far we have come, or receded, over the years, in the area of cultural enlightenment.

In a larger sense Aaron's images and the Shaman's legacy speak to one of the core questions of the 21st Century. Will the transformative power of the creative process be given the air and water and soil necessary to grow the vision we will need to bring our world into balance in the third millennium? Will the arts infuse our lives, our institutions, our communities, to help us make sense of, and find meaning in the confusion of the high speed, change constant, chaotic global community we are becoming?

With my friends introduced and the posing of these questions as a preamble, I would like move even further afield, out of the arts temple, and into the secular world, by sharing the first of three lists I will bludgeon you with this afternoon. This is a list of eight major big-deal events and forces that will have a significant impact on our communities and ultimately our cultural and community futures. I call them global transitions.

Before I start my list I would like to note that the following are culled from multiple sources and influences that include: The Report of the World Commission on Culture and Development, High Performance magazine, Fast Company magazine, Superman comic book, Peter Senge's Fifth Discipline Fieldbook, Lester Thurow's new book, The Future of Capitalism and numerous undisciplined careenings through the Internet.

1. First we have the fall of Communism
As we all know the walls came tumbling down. The global deck is getting reshuffled. We've moved from one-on-one five-card stud to 52-card pick up almost overnight. And as the rules of the game changed 1.9 Billion people who lived under communist regimes put down their playing cards and started playing monopoly. Not just as customers and producers but as competitors as well.

2. Globalization of cultural processes and products
The US and the west are rapidly losing dominance of the cultural marketplace. World literature, music, visual arts and media are emerging as readily from Bombay, Rio, or Seoul, as they are from New York, London or Paris. In 1975, only 7% of all of the cultural goods exported in the world came from what are called developing countries. (These include literature, music, visual arts, cinema, radio, television, photography and much more.) By 1991 this figure had increased to 28% of the worlds total. This is a four fold increase in just 16 years.

3. The ascendancy of man-made brain powered industries.
Lester Thurow points out that for more than 100 years the richest person in the world was connected to the oil industry. John D. Rockefeller in the late 19th century—Sultan of Brunei at the end of the 20th. Fifteen weeks ago Bill Gates became the richest man in the world. For the first time in world history someone who does not control natural resources is at the top of the material heap. In 1900, of the twelve largest industrial firms in US, 10 were natural resource based industries. Today, only one of those industries: General Electric, is still in business. Here's the Japanese ministry of international trade and industry's 1990 list of industrial priorities: micro electronics, biotechnology, designer materials, civilian aircraft industries, telecommunications, robotics, and computers. None are natural resource-based. America's fruited plains becoming less and less relevant on the global economic stage.

4. A Growing Worldwide Spiritual Revival
As the world has become less and less predictable more and more people are looking for meaning beyond the material. This has caused a dramatic increase in traditional and non-traditional religious and spiritual practice all over the world. Everything from fundamentalism to the psychic network figures in the explosion of spiritual questing. There is a guy named Watts Wacker who is a futurist at Stanford Research International. His job is to predict driving forces in the world. He says that in that part of the world that is supersaturated with physical stuff, status will hinge on what is scarce. He posits that spiritual experiences are becoming increasingly important because for the past 100 years we have imagined "stuff" as equal in meaning to the transcendent. He says that following the information age and the preeminence of the knowledge worker we will transition into something called the dream society in which we will place enormous stock in the spiritual and—surprise, surprise—the story tellers in our midst.

5. Unprecedented Demographic Upheavals
People are on the move all over the world for a lot of reasons, at unprecedented rates. From the middle 1980s to the middle '90s legal and illegal immigration, economic upheaval, military action, and starvation have caused a movement of over 120 million people from one country to another. This is the largest shift in human population in the history of the world and it is continuing.

6. The Global Economy
We now have all the technology in place to have a truly global economy. Thurow points out that before the industrial revolution the marketplace was local. In the Industrial Age locally centered economies gave way to national economic systems. Now we have entered the era of global economics. Capitol, raw materials, labor, manufacturing, marketing, all are disbursed around the world.

Here is an example : The air bag systems in our new cars depend on a little part called an accelerometer. It costs $50. It is designed and made in Boston, then sent to the Philippines for testing, then sent to Taiwan for packaging, on to Germany for installation in a BMW, and finally back the US to be sold by a dealer to someone not working for a state arts agency. So, I guess its fairly obvious that now there is no such thing as a truly German or American car.

7. The emergence of networked systems as the dominant organizational scheme
In 1992 I helped to facilitate a discussion among scholars and educational leaders sponsored by the Getty and the American Council of Learned Societies called Technology, Scholarship and the Humanities. A goodly number of those participating thought the discussion would focus on how America's academies were going to use technology to reinforce and maintain it's authority over academic discourse. They were disabused of this fantasy by the invited cyber jocks who informed them that what little control they had left would be long gone by the end of the century. This is now the case or becoming the case in most areas of human material and intellectual interaction. The flip side of this equation, of course, is the diminishing effectiveness and dominance of hierarchies as the prime tool for the management and distribution of power.

8. Given all this, for the first time in 50 years the United States and its western partners will not be writing the rules that will determine the world's economic and political future. So, America, must now learn to operate in an environment of shifting, toppling, and even flattening hierarchies—a world where information technology, multinational finance, world famine, ethnic conflict and ozone depletion are but a few of the interconnecting threads in the emerging global fabric.

Okay, so indications are that we are stand poised on the edge a world in the middle of multiple social and economic transitions. So what else is new? Well I'll tell you, whether we like it or not, this is unprecedented in the history of the world. The velocity and depth of these shifts are having, and will continue to have, an ever increasing impact on our lives. Not just because materials and mechanics of the economic, political and social realms are being turned upside down. No not just that. There are some more basic shifts taking place in the way we perceive the world we live in that are probably having an even greater effect on our daily lives.

These are what I will call, perceptual transitions.

1. The first relates to what we know and don't know.
Think about it. Now, for the first time, science text books are saying, "Scientists now think," or "based on the most current research we feel that..." When I went to school, knowledge came in a box. The label said eat and ye shall know. We were led to believe that all the basic stuff had been figured out. History was linear, math was finite, and the Newtonian physics promised a controlled and predictable future. And now, surprise! Everything is being reconsidered.

2. The second perceptual transition is our understanding of how things work. Not only is everything being reconsidered and redefined—we are now being told that the central unifying, constant, organizing principle of the universe is something called chaos. And chaos doesn't mean random craziness any more. Oh no! It means apparent random craziness that is actually organized and interconnected in some very complex ways that, unfortunately, are not all that predictable.

3. The third perceptual transition is that although the pace of change is increasing exponentially—we don't know it. We know things are going fast, but in order to cope we are getting used to getting used to things at a much faster rate. That means for some people, the good old days are the 1980's. And as the rate and volume of change increases our capacity to process and retain information is overtaxed—as a result we are more inclined to focus on the immediate and lose our long range perspective. In other words, we are losing our memories and our sense of history.

4. The fourth perceptual transition relates to our beliefs
There is a real revolution going on rooted in our struggle over changing values. Very little of what was considered the cultural norm during the first half of the 20th Century has not been altered in one way or another. As we begin the last decade of the century, the debate intensifies over such core issues as the loss of the nuclear family, the changing roles of men and women, the definition of right and wrong, our relationship to the earth, the distribution of wealth, freedom of expression, the importance of cultural identity and much more.

Some see the changes in values and beliefs that have taken place as a disintegration of the basic tenants of the American cultural fabric. To others, we are finally grappling with the gap between our stated ideals and the entrenched self-interest of the established power structure. In some sectors this questioning of values has precipitated a rekindling of the American spirit of creativity and innovation. In others the response has been defensive and reactionary.

Regardless of your point of view, these rapid changes in what we know, how things work, and what we believe, can be hard to take. We are moving from an era when we thought we were just moments away from nailing down all of the loose ends of the last few big questions, to new era that seems to have more questions than it does answers. I call this the end of the age of Certainty.

So right about now some of you are probably thinking, this is interesting stuff, but what has it got to do with the matter at hand? We're arts folks. This guy doesn't think all this global picture, paradigm-shifting, multinational organism talk is truly relevant to our single cell little selves sitting here in Cleveland does he? This is all abstract distant stuff. He's not crazy enough to think that we are players in the giant, enormous scheme of things here does he?

Well yes I do. Big time! You gotta remember. About 20 years ago a bunch of us CETA arts refugees started making art with prisoners and homeless folks and kids in community centers and went around talking about how people in the arts community ought to maybe think about finding new ways to connect to the rest of community life. And before that many others like Luis Valdez and El Teatro Campesino in California, And Bob Fitzgerald and Living Stage in Washington DC were doing similar stuff. And before that was Jack Jackson in LA and Bob Gard in Wisconsin and before them there were the WPA folks. And you need to remember that for the most part, most people thought this art and community thing was either irrelevant or insane, or both. And now you can't pick up a brochure or funding guidelines from a major arts funder in this country without the words "art" and "community" appearing together at least ten times. Now that hasn't been all good. And that's another conversation for another time. But I think we have a great tradition of crazy talk in this field that has planted some interesting seeds so I'll ask you to bear with me a little longer while I get a little crazier.

Now I'm going to ask you to exercise your imaginations. I am going to ask you to suspend your protective coat of cynicism to fantasize that we are convened here today in the year 2005 to conduct the world largest peer-panel meeting.

SLIDE: WELCOME 2005

We have before us eleven preliminary proposals, a cross section of our changing arts community. Our job is to decide whether to provide planning money for the further development of these proposals. Since this is a big group we are going to conduct this panel kind of like the Roman Forum. So after I briefly describe each proposal I will call for your yeas and neas.

Proposal #1. Artist Saves Small Town: The first proposal comes from a small rural farm town of 5,000 whose citizens generally feel that the high point in their history had been reached some 35-40 years ago. A town that has taken out its resentments about its diminished stature on itself—engaging periodically in endless rounds of bitter name-calling and finger pointing in veiled and cryptic references in public, and wholesale scapegoating behind closed doors and outright violence among some of the younger members of the community. The local church is proposing to hire a visual artist to come to town for six months to work with all of the towns people to rebuild the community's once positive self image and reconcile the warring factions.

Proposal #2. Art Saves Suburbs: This proposal is from a suburban area outside a major city. A community that was once booming when urban flight was just beginning. But now people are moving out, the schools are going down hill and the economy is in decline. The local arts council is asking for funds to open an old school to provide some cheap office space and basic office equipment for the remaining arts organizations. They would also like to use county employees to provide technical assistance and use other local government resources to respond to the ongoing needs of these organizations. They see this as a community economic development initiative. They anticipate the it will have a significant impact on the declining economy and image of the community.

Proposal #3. Artist Heals School/Community: The third proposal comes from the city. A team of community workers, sociologists, foundation executives and school officials have been working to address the problems associated with the rapid racial diversification of the city's schools. There has been an increase in racial incidents at schools and in the community, neighborhoods and schools becoming more and more segregated and fear and stereotype are dominating the political debate. The partnership of researchers and education leaders submitting this proposal have been unable to translate valuable findings of years of research to alter the complex web of attitudes, behaviors, policies, stereotypes and fear dominate this issue. They are asking for funding to hire an artist to become a part of their team of experts to help them come up with a new way to engage the community with their research findings and recommendations.

Proposal #4. Arts Ed Goes Global: This is a proposal to subsidize travel for a group of artists, arts educators, and arts administrators to attend an arts and education symposium in Scotland. The Symposium will be attended by artists and the principal education leaders from the EC countries. The symposium has no published agenda and will be organized by the participants on site to address one question: How will the arts and education help develop the capable, caring people needed to sustain our communities?

Proposal #5. Artists Invade Bureaucracy: This is a proposal from an arts organization that wants to convince government agencies and corporations to hire artists as consultants and researchers. Their aim is to place artists in positions where they can directly influence the decision-making processes of these organizations by giving artists an opportunity interact artistically with their bureaucracies. Proposed pilot projects include working with the Department of Transportation to investigate traffic accident patterns in two cities, and the development of a proposal for a cleanup of a toxic waste dump with local and Federal environmental agencies.

Proposal #6. Artist as Art: This is a residency proposal by an artist who defines most of his life's activities as art. He does not see his efforts in the realms of politics, education, and social change as separate from his creative endeavors. He says, in fact, that these actions are his art. This artist would like to create an environmentally based political movement as a community sculpture and produce a performance where he spends a weekend in a gallery with a coyote.

Proposal #7. Art Saves Industry: This is a proposal from an arts school and one of the worlds largest auto manufacturers. The car folks have a factory full of robot workers who are breaking down all the time. They are interested in joining with the arts school to train some of their engineers in visual arts and music. They think this will help their engineers better understand and anticipate the robots needs and shortcomings.

Proposal #8. Museum as Art/Artist as Museum: This is a proposal for general operating support from a brand new 200,000 square foot museum located in a large city. The museum describes its focus as presenting artwork and events that are cool, fun and, definitely neat. The museum's director is also its chief curator, designer, architect, and principal resident artist. The lineup of inaugural exhibitions include: a glass artist in residence, numerous monumental sculptures, a exhibition of dinosaur skeletons from Russia, a resident circus, a waterfall, a windmill , and a museum within the museum that features the worlds largest pair of jockey shorts and a presentation on the history of the corn dog.

Proposal #9. Warden as Impresario: This proposal comes from a Warden at the state's maximum security prison. The 10,000 inmates and staff members she supervises constitute the State's 11th largest community. The Warden is proposing a concert and lecture series at the prison for inmates and staff that would include The Kronos String Quartet, BB King, Carlos Fuentes, Gil Scott Herron, Jonathan Borofsky and an inmate production of Waiting for Godot developed in partnership with the Royal Swedish Theater.

Proposal #10. It seems that over the years the CIA has put a lot of effort into teaching some military folks in Central and South America some interesting ways to get people to tell their stories. This is a joint request from a local college and a theater company. They want support for a collaboration with the State Department to a create a theater-based institute that would help some of these truth squad guys eliminate their nasty habits.

Proposal #11. Artist Rousts Crackheads! Our final proposal comes from a desperate inner-city community. A small group of citizens living in a three-block area have been trying to rid their community of a crack house. Prior to the submission of this proposal these community members engaged law enforcement, the city's zoning officials, and their representative at city hall, all to no avail. They would like to hire an artist to help them develop a community mural project to drive these dope peddlers out of their community.

Now you may think that fantasizing like this is a waste of time. But I think is it useful to stretch your minds a little by entertaining the impossible. I also think it is important because I believe in short order mixed-up scenarios like these will not seem so crazy.

Given this, I think I have a responsibility to you to describe how I imagine the changes I have described and these fantastic proposals are connected. And how I think the arts world is going to ride these changes into the strange and fabulous future represented in these fantasies.

Let me start by saying, straight out, that in light of the social, political, economic, ethical, and spiritual changes and upheaval that are afoot in the world I believe the future health of our communities depends upon our ability to learn, to innovate, to solve problems, and most importantly to educate our kids so they become the adaptive, and flexible change agents we will need to make sense of the 21st Century. I also believe our ability to do this depends upon the tenacity, morality and the vitality with which we make use of our creative capacities. And, to reprise that famous poster of Uncle Sam pointing out at the nation's citizenry—This means you! Not just to provide a theme song, or a poster or an after school educational enhancement, but as the public arts leaders you need to be center stage at the community's table. How, you might say. I'm not going to be able to draw a map but here are five things to consider on the way.

1. First—the mundane, Politics.
We have to be cognizant of the conscious and unconscious roles we have been cast in on the American political stage. And we also need to be aware that if there ever was a place where chaos was at work in the world it is certainly the interplay of seemingly disconnected events that appear to end up determining American cultural policies.

We all know that for some in Washington, the deflation of the evil empire has left a void that is eliciting some incredibly imaginative, compensating behavior. And we know that the role of Boris Badinov has been replaced by hordes of extras cast as cultural perverts and subversives roaming the streets at night. Its unfortunate, but I think this kind of political projection is going to continue, for a variety of reasons.

But you know there have been times when we have cast ourselves as the deer in the headlights in our version of this movie and I don't think we can continue in this way. How do we change our political state of affairs?

To begin with, we could stop talking in codes that scare folks away.

We also need to be clear that we will always be politically vulnerable until there is a critical mass of people in this country who know the arts as a life-connected personal experience—not some other worldly event in some far away land.

Finally, we need to get straight that if we can't find the courage and strategies to support individual artists we are shooting ourselves in both feet.

2. Opportunity
The second thing we need to recognize is the enormous opportunity, and maybe obligation, that the change-constant world we are living in offers the creative community. To live in a world where change is the only constant, we must teach and prepare people to take responsibility for and respond constructively to situations and outcomes that cannot be predicted—situations that are not foreseen. Not every once in a while, but most of the time. Whether we like it or not, life is going to be less and less symphonic and more and more like jazz.

This, of course, is the language and technology of the creative process. Artists already know this song. The arts have been teaching people to think on their feet, to improvise on a changing theme in a structured way, to make things without knowing the outcome, or desired end. and to engage in leaderless collaboration for thousands of years.

Adaptation, flexibility and creativity—freedom balanced by form—integrating the head, hand and heart through discipline and imagination—these are the components of the technology of the creative processes that will be valuable and needed in the non-hierarchical/change-constant 21st Century.

If this sounds both scary and exciting to you I'm with you. And if you think the prospect of riding this roller coaster is disconcerting to you, think what it will feel like to an eight- or eleven-year-old child. But I've got news for you—whether we like it or not many of our children already live in this world.

3. SLIDE

So number 3 is making arts based education available to every child, every Aaron, in our communities who is going to have to make his way on the superhighway of the next millennium. This is a matter of critical national importance.

4. A Different Cultural Future
We need to open our eyes to the fact that the forces I have described here today will very likely shape a cultural future that is very different. Lets face it, in many ways we are a marginalized community. I think for some artists and arts organizations this state of affairs is about to change. I think in very short order some members of the perpetually marginalized arts community are going to find themselves invited to the big dance.

By this I mean that in the face of the depth and velocity of the enormous changes that are taking place in the global environment the commercial, scientific, academic, government, and social infrastructures of this and other countries will recognize the functional utility of creative process experts in the change constant environment I described earlier in my talk. Yes, as crazy as it may seem I'm saying that artists will be asked to apply creative process technology to the problems, needs, and desires of the power elite.

Now if you think I'm insane, please know that this idea did not originate with me. It has been a central part of policy and legislative deliberations at the Dutch Parliament, the European Community Council of Europe, the United Nations, and in hundreds of industries all around the world. Even the folks who make Malto-Meal have a resident artist working on the shop floor.

5. Changes
Fifth and finally, I think all of these transitions are going to bring elemental changes in the way we do business as artists, as arts organizations. I believe the continued flattening of hierarchies through the evolution of electronic networks is going to dramatically alter the patterns of cultural power in this country and the world. We have seen this at work in the worlds of clothing design and music for years. For all of the horsepower that has been vested in the design and music centers in Los Angeles and New York, global youth and third world aesthetics dominate these industries. More and more the most interesting and creative ideas are being developed away from the centers of economic and political power.

As the networking and connecting continues to spread, it is more likely that innovations by artists, or in the areas of arts education or public arts policy will come from off center. In small towns where the intransigence and gridlock of politics and self interest do not dominate all policy. In mid-sized cities where artists have re-located to raise their families and make art in economies that make sense. In virtual collaborative networks that allow artists from across the world to forge creative partnerships that were unimaginable even five years ago.

Now, I have a confession to make. These fantasies I shared with you earlier in my talk are all true. Here is the truth about these fantasies.

1. Artist Saves Town: In Guadelupe, California, in 1989 a muralist and community activist Judy Baca came to town. She engaged young people to interview the rest of the town about its history. Through the project she was able to cross the cultural and economic barriers that divided the town. Judy's extraordinary artistry and diplomacy over these six months engaged the disparate feuding elements of the community in an honest and open airing of grievances and multiple readings of history. Her work culminated in a three-day community-wide celebration of the community's heritage and the creation of the town's first historical society.

2. Artist Saves Suburbs: Last year Arts Incubator in Arlington, Virginia, became the first arts program to win an Innovations in American Government Award from Harvard University's Kennedy School of Government and the Ford Foundation. Since its inception in 1990, the number of arts groups located in Arlington County has increased by 150%, and audiences have increased from 100,000 in 1990 to 300,000 people in 1995, nearly twice the county's population. As a result, the county's arts community has grown to become a $5 million per year industry.

3. Arts Ed goes global: The British American Arts Association, the Scottish Consultative Council on Education and a European Community Educational Consortium are convening the top folks from seven European countries and the US to talk about the creation of arts-based curricula that emphasizes both academic skills and capacities and values.

4. Artists invade Bureaucracy: In the 1960s and '70s during the previous Labour government an arts group called Organization and Imagination placed artists as workers in a wide range of high level policy, planning and design efforts in such areas as health, redevelopment, transportation and education.

5. Artist as Art: These proposals were a few of the hundreds of "actions" or "social sculptures" created by German artist Joseph Beuys in the '60s and '70s.

6. Arts Saves Industry: In Munich Germany, in the giant Volkswagen plant there where they make a car called the Golf there is a robot-run assembly line where no human hands touch the evolving cars. Early on in the operation the plant engineers realized that computers alone were not anticipating the kinds of breakdowns they were encountering. They provided a year of intensive special visual arts, music and dance training to a new kind of plant engineer. This engineer's job is to listen and watch the chaos of complex movements and sounds of robot teams. Their training has given these engineers the capacity to hear and see subtle changes in the robot dance and robot songs and accurately anticipate and prevent breakdowns.

7. Museum as Art/Artist as Museum: Its all true at the City Museum in St. Louis which just opened. I recommend it highly.

8. Warden as Impresario
These are just a sampling of the kinds of programming that has taken place over the past 15 years under the auspices of California's Arts-in-Corrections Program, with help from the California Arts Council. This program, which I had the pleasure of heading for eight years, regularly provides tens of thousands of inmates with the highest quality arts programs delivered by some of the state's finest artists. The result has been safer prisons and reduced recidivism.

9. Artist Rousts Crackheads. Artist Normando Ismay collaborated with young people in his community in Atlanta, Georgia, to paint signs and decorate the area around a crack house to draw attention to the activities taking place inside. With all the attention, customers shied away and the crack dealers moved out.

10. Artists Help Eliminate Nasty Habits: In the Early 1990s congress did, in fact decide that our torture training program was a bad thing. So they asked the State Department to enlist John Jay College, who in turn, enlisted John Bergman's Geese Theater Company to do a number on a group of invited captains and colonels. Amazingly enough John's work did begin to produce some born-again reformers. That was not expected, so they canceled it.

11. Artist Heals Schools
In the Twin Cities the St. Paul Foundation invested heavily on a longitudinal study of the diversification of the city's schools. It was anticipated that these findings would have a significant impact on the awareness of the problems, and produce behavior and attitude changes in the schools and community. When none of this occurred the foundation turned to COMPAS, a local community arts provider, who in turn, turned to an accomplished writer of fiction. They asked this writer to turn the hundreds of pages of charts, graphs, and case studies into a work of fiction that told the story of the diversification of the community's schools in all its complexity, so that its readers could hear and see and feel and remember the lessons learned through the research. This book is being touted as a new and effective tool for diversity training and awareness.

This last story brings us full circle into the realm of the words written by Aaron. To close the circle I would like to repeat this short song. And as I do I would ask you to hear the words as they relate not just to Aaron's new found vision , but to your work back home and the importance of our making that ticket a part of the lives of all of the people of the communities we serve.

Darkness is a way of life
when you don't know the way.
When you find the way, darkness shatters
like an old glass bottle.
A ticket falls out
A ticket to a lifetime of love

William Cleveland is the director of the Center for the Study of Art and Community, based in Minneapolis, MN, and is the author of "Art in Other Places: Artists at Work in America's Community and Social Institutions," Praeger, 1992.


above copied from: http://www.communityarts.net/readingroom/archivefiles/1999/12/chaos_art_and_t.php

Introduction: Modern, Postmodern, and Contemporary, Arthur Danto



At roughly the same moment, but quite in ignorance of one another's thought, the German art historian Hans Belting and I both published texts on the end of art.(1) Each of us had arrived at a vivid sense that some momentous historical shift had taken place in the productive conditions of the visual arts, even if, outwardly speaking, the institutional complexes of the art world--the galleries, the art schools, the periodicals, the museums, the critical establishment, the curatorial--seemed relatively stable. Belting has since published an amazing book, tracing the history of devotional images in the Christian West from late Roman times until about A.D. 1400, to which he gave the striking subtitle The Image before the Era of Art. It was not that those images were not art in some large sense, but their being art did not figure in their production, since the concept of art had not as yet really emerged in general consciousness, and such images--icons, really--played quite different role in the lives of people than works of art came to play when the concept at last emerged and something like aesthetic considerations began to govern our relationships to them. They were not even thought of as art in the elementary sense of having been produced by artists--human beings putting marks on surfaces--but were regarded as having a miraculous provenance, like the imprinting of Jesus's image on Veronica's veil.(2) There would then have been a profound discontinuity between artistic practices before and after the era of art had begun, since the concept of the artist did not enter into the explanation of devotional images,(3) but of course the concept of the artist became central in the Renaissance, to the point that Giorgio Vasari was to write a great book on the lives of the artists. Before then there would at best have been the lives of the dabbling saints.

If this is at all thinkable, then there might be another discontinuity, no less profound, between the art produced during the era of art and art produced after that era ended. The era of art did not begin abruptly in 1400, nor did it end sharply either, sometime before the mid-1980s when Belting's and my texts appeared respectively in German and in English. Neither of us, perhaps, had as clear an idea as we now might have, ten years later, of what we were trying to say, but, now that Belting has come forward with the idea of art before the beginning of art, we might think about art after the end of art, as if we were emerging from the era of art into something else the exact shape and structure of which remains to be understood.

Neither of us intended our observations as a critical judgment regarding the art of our time. In the eighties, certain radical theorists had taken up the theme of the death of painting and had based their judgment on the claim that advanced painting seemed to show all the signs of internal exhaustion, or at least marked limits beyond which it was not possible to press. They were thinking of Robert Ryman's more or less all-white paintings, or perhaps the aggressive monotonous stripe paintings of the French artist Daniel Buren; and it would be difficult not to consider their account as in some way a critical judgment, both on those artists and on the practice of painting in general. But it was quite consistent with the end of the era of art, as Belting and I understood it, that art should be extremely vigorous and show no sign whatever of internal exhaustion. Ours was a claim about how one complex of practices had given way to another, even if the shape of the new complex was still unclear--is still unclear. Neither of us was talking about the death of art, though my own text happens to have appeared as the target article in a volume under the title The Death of Art. That title was not mine, for I was writing about a certain narrative that had, I thought, been objectively realized in the history of art, and it was that narrative, it seemed to me, that had come to an end. A story was over. It was not my view that there would be no more art, which "death" certainly implies, but that whatever art there was to be would be made without benefit of a reassuring sort of narrative in which it was seen as the appropriate next stage in the story. What had come to an end was that narrative but not the subject of the narrative. I hasten to clarify.

In a certain sense, life really begins when the story comes to an end, as in the story every couple relishes of how they found one another and "lived happily ever after."(4) In the German genre of the Bildungsroman--the novel of formation and self-discovery--the story is told of the stages through which the hero or heroine progresses on the way to self-awareness. The genre has almost become a matrix of the feminist novel in which the heroine arrives at a consciousness of who she is and what being a woman means. And that awareness, though the end of the story, is really "the first day of the rest of her life," to use the somewhat corny phrase of New Age philosophy. Hegel's early masterpiece, The Phenomenology of Spirit, has the form of a Bildungsroman, in the sense that its hero, Geist, goes through a sequence of stages in order to achieve knowledge not merely of what it itself is, but that without the history of mishaps and misplaced enthusiasms, its knowledge would be empty.(5) Belting's thesis too was about narratives. "Contemporary art," he wrote, "manifests an awareness of a history of art but no longer carries it forward."(6) And he speaks as well of "the relatively recent loss of faith in a great and compelling narrative, in the way things must be seen."(7) It is in part the sense of no longer belonging to a great narrative, registering itself on our consciousness somewhere between uneasiness and exhilaration, that marks the historical sensibility of the present, and which, if Belting and I are at all on the right path, helps define the acute difference, of which I think that awareness only began to emerge in the mid-1970s, between modern and contemporary art. It is characteristic of contemporaneity--but not of modernity--that it should have begun insidiously, without slogan or logo, without anyone being greatly aware that it had happened. The Armory show of 1913 used the pine-tree flag of the American Revolution as its logo to celebrate a repudiation of the art of the past. The Berlin dada movement proclaimed the death of art, but on the same poster by Raoul Hausmann wished long life to "The Machine Art of Tatlin." Contemporary art, by contrast, has no brief against the art of the past, no sense that the past is something from which liberation must be won, no sense even that it is at all different as art from modern art generally. It is part of what defines contemporary art that the art of the past is available for such use as artists care to give it. What is not available to them is the spirit in which the art was made. The paradigm of the contemporary is that of the collage as defined by Max Ernst, with one difference. Ernst said that collage is "the meeting of two distant realities on a plane foreign to them both."(8) The difference is that there is no longer a plane foreign to distinct artistic realities, nor are those realities all that distant from one another. That is because the basic perception of the contemporary spirit was formed on the principle of a museum in which all art has a rightful place, where there is no a priori criterion as to what that art must look like, and where there is no narrative into which the museum's contents must all fit. Artists today treat museums as filled not with dead art, but with living artistic options. The museum is a field available for constant rearrangement, and indeed there is an art form emerging which uses the museum as a repository of materials for a collage of objects arranged to suggest or support a thesis; we see it in Fred Wilson's installation at the Maryland Historical Museum and again in Joseph Kosuth's remarkable installation "The Play of the Unmentionable" at the Brooklyn Museum.(9) But the genre is almost commonplace today: the artist is given free run of the museum and organizes out of its resources exhibitions of objects that have no historical or formal connection to one another other than what the artist provides. In some way the museum is cause, effect, and embodiment of the attitudes and practices that define the post-historical moment of art, but I do not want to press the matter for the moment. Rather, I want to return to the distinction between the modern and the contemporary and discuss its emergence into consciousness. In fact, it was the dawning of a certain kind of self-consciousness that I had in mind when I began to write about the end of art.

In my own field, philosophy, the historical divisions went roughly as follows: ancient, medieval, and modern. "Modern" philosophy was generally thought to begin with Rene Descartes, and what distinguished it was the particular inward turn Descartes took--his famous reversion to the "I think"--where the question would be less how things really are than how someone whose mind is structured in a certain way is obliged to think they are. Whether things really are the way the structure of our mind requires us to think they are is not something we can say. But neither does it greatly matter, since we have no alternative way of thinking about them. So working from the inside outward, so to speak, Descartes, and modern philosophy generally, drew a philosophical map of the universe whose matrix was the structure of human thought. What Descartes did was begin to bring the structures of thought to consciousness, where we could examine them critically and come to understand at one and the same time what we are and how the world is, for since the world is defined by thought, the world and we are literally made in one another's image. The ancients simply went ahead endeavoring to describe the world, paying no attention to those subjective features modern philosophy made central. We could paraphrase Hans Belting's marvelous title by talking about the self before the era of the self to mark the difference between ancient and modern philosophy. It is not that there were no selves before Descartes, but that the concept of the self did not define the entire activity of philosophy, as it came to do after he had revolutionized it and until reversion to language came to replace reversion to the self. And while "the linguistic turn"(10) certainly replaced questions of what we are with how we talk, there is an undoubted continuity between the two stages of philosophical thought, as is underscored by Noam Chomsky's description of his own revolution in the philosophy of language as "Cartesian linguistics,"(11) replacing or augmenting Descartes's theory of innate thought with the postulation of innate linguistic structures.

There is an analogy to the history of art. Modernism in art marks a point before which painters set about representing the world the way it presented itself, painting people and landscapes and historical events just as they would present themselves to the eye. With modernism, the conditions of representation themselves become central, so that art in a way becomes its own subject. This was almost precisely the way in which Clement Greenberg defined the matter in his famous 1960 essay "Modernist Painting." "The essence of Modernism," he wrote, "lies, as I see it, in the use of the characteristic methods of a discipline to criticize the discipline itself, not in order to subvert it but in order to entrench it more firmly in its area of competence."(12) Interestingly, Greenberg took as his model of modernist thought the philosopher Immanuel Kant: "Because he was the first to criticize the means itself of criticism, I conceive of Kant as the first real Modernist." Kant did not see philosophy as adding to our knowledge so much as answering the question of how knowledge was possible. And I suppose the corresponding view of painting would have been not to represent the appearances of things so much as answering the question of how painting was possible. The question then would be: who was the first modernist painter--who deflected the art of painting from its representational agenda to a new agenda in which the means of representation became the object of representation?

For Greenberg, Manet became the Kant of modernist painting: "Manes's became the first Modernist pictures by virtue of the frankness with which they declared the flat surfaces on which they were painted." And the history of modernism moved from there through the impressionists, "who abjured underpainting and glazes, to leave the eye under no doubt as to the fact that the colors they used were made of paint that came from tubes or pots," to Cezanne, who "sacrificed verisimilitude, or correctness, in order to fit his drawing and design more explicitly to the rectangular shape of the canvas." And step by step Greenberg constructed a narrative of modernism to replace the narrative of the traditional representational painting defined by Vasari. Flatness, the consciousness of paint and brushstroke, the rectangular shape--all of them what Meyer Schapiro speaks of as "nonmimetic features" of what may still have been residually mimetic paintings--displaced perspective, foreshortening, chiaroscuro as the progress points of a developmental sequence. The shift from "premodernist" to modernist art, if we follow Greenberg, was the shift from mimetic to nonmimetic features of painting. It was not, Greenberg asserts, that painting had to become itself nonobjective or abstract. It was just that its representational features were secondary in modernism where they had been primary in premodernist art. Much of my book, concerned as it is with narratives of the history of art, must perforce deal with Greenberg as the great narrativist of modernism.

It is important that the concept of modernism, if Greenberg is right, is not merely the name of a stylistic period which begins in the latter third of the nineteenth century, the way in which Mannerism is the name of a stylistic period which begins in the first third of the sixteenth century: Mannerist follows Renaissance painting and is followed by the baroque, which is followed by rococo, which is followed by neoclassicism, which is followed by the romantic. These were deep changes in the way painting represents the world, changes, one might say, in coloration and mood, and they develop out of and to some degree in reaction against their predecessors, as well as in response to all sorts of extra-artistic forces in history and in life. My sense is that modernism does not follow romanticism in this way, or not merely: it is marked by an ascent to a new level of consciousness, which is reflected in painting as a kind of discontinuity, almost as if to emphasize that mimetic representation had become less important than some kind of reflection on the means and methods of representation. Painting begins to look awkward, or forced (in my own chronology it is Van Gogh and Gauguin who are the first modernist painters). In effect, modernism sets itself at a distance from the previous history of art, I suppose in the way in which adults, in the words of Saint Paul, "put aside childish things." The point is that "modern" does not merely mean "the most recent."

It means, rather, in philosophy as well as in art, a notion of strategy and style and agenda. If it were just a temporal notion, all the philosophy contemporary with Descartes or Kant and all the painting contemporary with Manet and Cezanne would be modernist, but in fact a fair amount of philosophizing went on which was, in Kant's terms, "dogmatic," having nothing to do with the issues which defined the critical program he advanced. Most of the philosophers contemporary with Kant but otherwise "precritical" have dropped out of sight of all save scholars of the history of philosophy. And while there remains a place in the museum for painting contemporary with modernist art which is not itself modernist--for example, French academic painting, which acted as if Cezanne had never happened, or later, surrealism, which Greenberg did what he could to suppress or, to use the psychoanalytical language which has come naturally to Greenberg's critics, like Rosalind Krauss or Hal Foster,(13) "to repress"--there is no room for it in the great narrative of modernism which swept on past it, into what came to be known as "abstract expressionism" (a label Greenberg disliked), and then color-field abstraction, where, though the narrative did not necessarily end, Greenberg himself stopped. Surrealism, like academic painting, lay, according to Greenberg, "outside the pale of history," to use an expression I found in Hegel. It happened, but it was not, significantly, part of the progress. If you were snide, as critics schooled in Greenbergian invective were, it was not really art, and that declaration showed the degree to which the identity of art was internally connected with being part of the official narrative. Hal Foster writes: "A space for surrealism has opened up: an impense within the old narrative, it has become a privileged point for the contemporary critique of this narrative."(14) Part of what the "end of art" means is the enfranchisement of what had lain beyond the pale, where the very idea of a pale--a wall--is exclusionary, the way the Great Wall of China was, built to keep the Mongol hordes outside, or as the Berlin Wall was built, to keep the innocent socialist population protected from the toxins of capitalism. (The great Irish-American painter Sean Scully delights in the fact that "the pale," in English, refers to the Irish Pale, an enclave in Ireland, making the Irish outsiders in their own land.) In the modernist narrative, art beyond the pale either is no part of the sweep of history, or it is a reversion to some earlier form of art. Kant once spoke of his own era, the Age of Enlightenment, as "mankind's coming of age." Greenberg might have thought of art in those terms as well, and seen in surrealism a kind of aesthetic regression, a reassertion of values from the childhood of art, filled with monsters and scary threats. For him, maturity meant purity, in a sense of the term that connects exactly to what Kant meant by the term in the title of his Critique of Pure Reason. This was reason applied to itself, and having no other subject. Pure art was correspondingly art applied to art. And surrealism was almost the embodiment of impurity, concerned as it was with dreams, the unconscious, eroticism, and, in Foster's vision of it, "the uncanny." But so, by Greenbergian criteria, is contemporary art impure, which is what I want to talk about now. Just as "modern" is not simply a temporal concept, meaning, say, "most recent," neither is "contemporary" merely a temporal term, meaning whatever is taking place at the present moment. And just as the shift from "premodern" to modern was as insidious as the shift, in Hans Belting's terms, from the image before the era of art to the image in the era of art, so that artists were making modern art without realizing they were doing anything different in kind until it began to be retrospectively clear that a momentous change had taken place, so, similarly, did it happen with the shift from modern to contemporary art. For a long time, I think, "contemporary art" would have been just the modern art that is being made now. Modern, after all, implies a difference between now and "back then": there would be no use for the expression if things remained steady and largely the same. It implies an historical structure and is stronger in this sense than a term like "most recent." "Contemporary" in its most obvious sense means simply what is happening now: contemporary art would be the art produced by our contemporaries. It would not, clearly, have passed the test of time. But it would have a certain meaning for us which even modern art which had passed that test would not have: it would be "our art" in some particularly intimate way. But as the history of art has internally evolved, contemporary has come to mean an art produced within a certain structure of production never, I think, seen before in the entire history of art. So just as "modern" has come to denote a style and even a period, and not just recent art, "contemporary" has come to designate something more than simply the art of the present moment. In my view, moreover, it designates less a period than what happens after there are no more periods in some master narrative of art, and less a style of making art than a style of using styles. Of course, there is contemporary art in styles of a kind never before seen, but I do not want to press the matter at this stage of my discussion. I merely wish to alert the reader to my effort to draw a very strong distinction between "modern" and"contemporary."(15)

I don't especially think that the distinction was sharply drawn when I first moved to New York at the end of the forties, when "our art" was modern art, and the Museum of Modern Art belonged to us in that intimate way. To be sure, a lot of art was being made which did not as yet make an appearance in that museum, but it did not seem to us then, to the degree that the matter was thought about at all, that the latter was contemporary in a way that distinguished it from modern. It seemed a wholly natural arrangement that some of this art would sooner or later find its way into "The Modern," and that this arrangement would continue indefinitely, modern art being here to stay, but not in any way forming a closed canon. It was not closed, certainly, in 1949, when Life magazine suggested that Jackson Pollock might just be the greatest American painter alive. That it is closed today, in the minds of many, myself included, means that somewhere between then and now a distinction emerged between the contemporary and the modern. The contemporary was no longer modern save in the sense of "most recent," and the modern seemed more and more to have been a style that flourished from about 1880 until sometime in the 1960s. It could even be said, I suppose, that some modern art continued to be produced after that--art which remained under the stylistic imperatives of modernism--but that art would not really be contemporary, except again in the strictly temporal sense of the term. For when the stylistic profile of modern art revealed itself, it did so because contemporary art itself revealed a profile very different from modern art. This tended to put the Museum of Modern Art in a kind of bind no one had anticipated when it was the home of "our art." The bind was due to the fact that "modern" had a stylistic meaning and a temporal meaning. It would not have occurred to anyone that these would conflict, that contemporary art would stop being modern art. But today, as we near the end of the century, the Museum of Modern Art has to decide whether it is going to acquire contemporary art that is not modern and thus become a museum of modern art in the strictly temporal sense or whether it will continue to collect only stylistically modern art, the production of which has thinned down to perhaps a trickle, but which is no longer representative of the contemporary world.

In any case, the distinction between the modern and the contemporary did not become clear until well into the seventies and eighties. Contemporary art would for a long time continue to be "the modern art produced by our contemporaries." At some point this clearly stopped being a satisfactory way of thinking, as evidenced by the need to invent the term "postmodern." That term by itself showed the relative weakness of the term "contemporary" as conveying a style. It seemed too much a mere temporal term. But perhaps "postmodern" was too strong a term, too closely identified with a certain sector of contemporary art. In truth, the term "postmodern" really does seem to me to designate a certain style we can learn to recognize, the way we learn to recognize instances of the baroque or the rococo. It is a term something like "camp," which Susan Sontag transferred from gay idiolect into common discourse in a famous essay.(16) One can, after reading her essay, become reasonably adept at picking out camp objects, in just the same way it seems to me that one can pick out postmodern objects, with maybe some difficulties at the borderlines. But that is how it is with most concepts, stylistic or otherwise, and with recognitional capacities in human beings and in animals. There is a valuable formula in Robert Venturi's 1966 book Complexity and Contradiction in Architecture: "elements which are hybrid rather than `pure,' compromising rather than `clean,' `ambiguous' rather than `articulated,' perverse as well as `interesting.'"(17) One could sort works of art out using this formula, and almost certainly you would have one pile which consisted pretty homogeneously of postmodern works. It would have the works of Robert Rauschenberg, the paintings of Julian Schnabel and David Salle, and I guess the architecture of Frank Gehry. But much contemporary art would be left out--say the works of Jenny Holzer or the paintings of Robert Mangold. It has been suggested that perhaps we should simply speak of postmodernisms. But once we do this, we lose the recognitional ability, the capacity to sort out, and the sense that postmodernism marks a specific style. We could capitalize the word "contemporary" to cover whatever the disjunction of postmodernisms was intended to cover, but there again we would be left with the sense that we have no identifiable style, that there is nothing that does not fit. But that in fact is the mark of the visual arts since the end of modernism, that as a period it is defined by the lack of a stylistic unity, or at least the kind of stylistic unity which can be elevated into a criterion and used as a basis for developing a recognitional capacity, and there is in consequence no possibility of a narrative direction. That is why I prefer to call it simply posthistorical art. Anything ever done could be done today and be an example of post-historical art. For example, an appropriationist artist like Mike Bidlo could have a show of Piero della Francescas in which the entirety of Piero's corpus was appropriated. Piero is certainly not a post-historical artist, but Bidlo is, and a skilled enough appropriationist as well, so that his Pieros and Piero's paintings could look as much alike as he cared to make them look--as much like Piero as his Morandis look like Morandis, his Picassos like Picassos, his Warhols like Warhols. Yet in an important sense, not easily believed accessible to the eye, Bidlo's Pieros would have more in common with the work of Jenny Holzer, Barbara Kruger, Cindy Sherman, and Sherrie Levine than with Piero's proper stylistic peers. So the contemporary is, from one perspective, a period of information disorder, a condition of perfect aesthetic entropy. But it is equally a period of quite perfect freedom. Today there is no longer any pale of history. Everything is permitted. But that makes the historical transition from modernism to post-historical art all the more urgent to try to understand. And that means that it is urgent to try to understand the decade of the 1970s, a period in its own way as dark as the tenth century.

The seventies was a decade in which it must have seemed that history had lost its way. It had lost its way because nothing at all like a discernible direction seemed to be emerging. If we think of 1962 as marking the end of abstract expressionism, then you had a number of styles succeeding one another at a dizzying rate: color-field painting, hard-edged abstraction, French neorealism, pop, op, minimalism, arte povera, and then what got to be called the New Sculpture, which included Richard Serra, Linda Benglis, Richard Tuttle, Eva Hesse, Barry Le Va, and then conceptual art. Then what seemed to be ten years of nothing much. There were sporadic movements like Pattern and Decoration, but nobody supposed they were going to generate the kind of structural stylistic energy of the immense upheavals of the sixties. Then all at once neo-expressionism arose, in the early eighties, and gave people the sense that a new direction had been found. And then again the sense of nothing much so far at least as historical directions were concerned. And then the dawning sense that the absence of direction was the defining trait of the new period, that neoexpressionism was less a direction than the illusion of one. Recently people have begun to feel that the last twenty-five years, a period of tremendous experimental productiveness in the visual arts with no single narrative direction on the basis of which others could be excluded, have stabilized as the norm.

The sixties was a paroxysm of styles, in the course of whose contention, it seems to me--and this was the basis of my speaking of the "end of art" in the first place--it gradually became clear, first through the nouveaux realistes and pop, that there was no special way works of art had to look in contrast to what I have designated "mere real things." To use my favorite example, nothing need mark the difference, outwardly, between Andy Warhol's Brillo Box and the Brillo boxes in the supermarket. And conceptual art demonstrated that there need not even be a palpable visual object for something to be a work of visual art. That meant that you could no longer teach the meaning of art by example. It meant that as far as appearances were concerned, anything could be a work of art, and it meant that if you were going to find out what art was, you had to turn from sense experience to thought. You had, in brief, to turn to philosophy.

In an interview in 1969, conceptual artist Joseph Kosuth claimed that the only role for an artist at the time "was to investigate the nature of art itself."(18) This sounds strikingly like the line in Hegel that gave support to my own views about the end of art: "Art invites us to intellectual consideration, and that not for the purpose of creating art again, but for knowing philosophically what art is."(19) Joseph Kosuth is a philosophically literate artist to an exceptional degree, and he was one of the few artists working in the sixties and seventies who had the resources to undertake a philosophical analysis of the general nature of art. As it happened, relatively few philosophers of the time were ready to do this, just because so few of them could have imagined the possibility of art like that being produced in such dizzying disjunctiveness. The philosophical question of the nature of art, rather, was something that arose within art when artists pressed against boundary after boundary, and found that the boundaries all gave way. All typical sixties artists had that vivid sense of boundaries, each drawn by some tacit philosophical definition of art, and their erasure has left us the situation we find ourselves in today. Such a world is not, by the way, the easiest kind of world to live in, which explains why the political reality of the present seems to consist in drawing and defining boundaries wherever possible. Nevertheless, it was only in the 1960s that a serious philosophy of art became a possibility, one which did not base itself on purely local facts--for example, that art was essentially painting and sculpture. Only when it became clear that anything could be a work of art could one think, philosophically, about art. Only then did the possibility arise of a true general philosophy of art. But what of art itself? What of "Art after Philosophy"--to use the title of Kosuth's essay--which, to make the point, may indeed itself be a work of art? What of art after the end of art, where, by "after the end of art," I mean "after the ascent to philosophical self-reflection?" Where an artwork can consist of any object whatsoever that is enfranchised as art, raising the question "Why am I a work of art?"

With that question the history of modernism was over. It was over because modernism was too local and too materialist, concerned as it was with shape, surface, pigment, and the like as defining painting in its purity. Modernist painting, as Greenberg defined it, could only ask the question "What is it that I have and that no other kind of art can have?" And sculpture asked itself the same kind of question. But what this gives us is no general picture of what art is, only what some of the arts, perhaps historically the most important arts, essentially were. What question does Warhol's Brillo Box ask, or one of Beuys's multiples of a square of chocolate stuck to a piece of paper? What Greenberg had done was to identify a certain local style of abstraction with the philosophical truth of art, when the philosophical truth, once found, would have to be consistent with art appearing every possible way.

What I know is that the paroxysms subsided in the seventies, as if it had been the internal intention of the history of art to arrive at a philosophical conception of itself, and that the last stages of that history were somehow the hardest to work through, as art sought to break through the toughest outer membranes, and so itself became, in the process, paroxysmal. But now that the integument was broken, now that at least the glimpse of self-consciousness had been attained, that history was finished. It had delivered itself of a burden it could now hand over to the philosophers to carry. And artists, liberated from the burden of history, were free to make art in whatever way they wished, for any purposes they wished, or for no purposes at all. That is the mark of contemporary art, and small wonder, in contrast with modernism, there is no such thing as a contemporary style.

I think the ending of modernism did not happen a moment too soon. For the art world of the seventies was filled with artists bent on agendas having nothing much to do with pressing the limits of art or extending the history of art, but with putting art at the service of this or that personal or political goal. And artists had the whole inheritance of art history to work with, including the history of the avant-garde, which placed at the disposition of the artist all those marvelous possibilities the avant-garde had worked out and which modernism did its utmost to repress. In my own view, the major artistic contribution of the decade was the emergence of the appropriated image--the taking over of images with established meaning and identity and giving them a fresh meaning and identity. Since any image could be appropriated, it immediately follows that there could be no perceptual stylistic uniformity among appropriated images. One of my favorite examples is Kevin Roche's 1992 addition to the Jewish Museum in New York. The old Jewish Museum was just the Warburg mansion on Fifth Avenue, with its baronial associations and connotations of the Gilded Age. Kevin Roche brilliantly decided to duplicate the old Jewish Museum, and the eye is unable to tell a single difference. But the building belongs to the postmodern age perfectly: a postmodern architect can design a building which looks like a Mannerist chateau. It was an architectural solution that had to have pleased the most conservative and nostalgic trustee, as well as the most avant-garde and contemporary one, but of course for quite different reasons.

These artistic possibilities are but realizations and applications of the immense philosophical contribution of the 1960s to art's self-understanding: that artworks can be imagined, or in fact produced, which look exactly like mere real things which have no claim to the status of art at all, for the latter entails that you can't define artworks in terms of some particular visual properties they may have. There is no a priori constraint on how works of art must look--they can look like anything at all. This alone finished the modernist agenda, but it had to wreak havoc with the central institution of the art world, namely the museum of fine arts. The first generation of great American museums took it for granted that its contents would be treasures of great visual beauty and that visitors would enter the tresorium to be in the presence of spiritual truth of which the visually beautiful was the metaphor. The second generation, of which the Museum of Modern Art is the great exemplar, assumed that the work of art is to be defined in formalist terms and appreciated under the perspective of a narrative not remarkably different from the one Greenberg advanced: a linear progressive history the visitor would work through, learning to appreciate the work of art together with learning the historical sequences. Nothing was to distract from the formal visual interest of the works themselves. Even picture frames were eliminated as distractions, or perhaps as concessions to an illusionistic agenda modernism had outgrown: paintings were no longer windows onto imagined scenes, but objects in their own right, even if they had been conceived as windows. It is, incidentally, easy to understand why surrealism has to be repressed in the light of such an experience: it would be too distracting, not to mention irrelevantly illusionistic. Works had plenty of space to themselves in galleries emptied of everything but those works.

In any case, with the philosophical coming of age of art, visuality drops away, as little relevant to the essence of art as beauty proved to have been. For art to exist there does not even have to be an object to look at, and if there are objects in a gallery, they can look like anything at all. Three attacks on established museums are worth noting in this respect. When Kirk Varnedoe and Adam Gopnick admitted pop into the galleries of the Museum of Modern Art in the "High and Low" show of 1990, there was a critical conflagration. When Thomas Krens deaccessioned a Kandinsky and a Chagall to acquire part of the Panza collection, a good bit of it conceptual and much of which did not exist as objects, there was a critical conflagration. And when, in 1993, the Whitney compiled a Biennial consisting of works that really typified the way the art world had gone after the end of art, the outpouring of critical hostility--in which I am afraid I shared--was by an inestimable factor unprecedented in the history of Biennial polemics. Whatever art is, it is no longer something primarily to be looked at. Stared at, perhaps, but not primarily looked at. What, in view of this, is a post-historical museum to do, or to be?

It must be plain that there are three models at least, depending upon the kind of art we are dealing with, and depending upon whether it is beauty, form, or what I shall term engagement that defines our relationship to it. Contemporary art is too pluralistic in intention and realization to allow itself to be captured along a single dimension, and indeed an argument can be made that enough of it is incompatible with the constraints of the museum that an entirely different breed of curator is required, one who bypasses museum structures altogether in the interests of engaging the art directly with the lives of persons who have seen no reason to use the museum either as tresorium of beauty or sanctum of spiritual form. For a museum to engage this kind of art, it has to surrender much of the structure and theory that define the museum in its other two modes.

But the museum itself is only part of the infrastructure of art that will sooner or later have to deal with the end of art and with art after the end of art. The artist, the gallery, the practices of art history, and the discipline of philosophical aesthetics must all, in one or another way, give way and become different, and perhaps vastly different, from what they have so far been. I can only hope to tell part of the philosophical story in the chapters that follow. The institutional story must wait upon history itself.

(C) 1997 the Trustees of the National Gallery of Art All rights reserved. ISBN: 0-691-01173-7

above copied from: http://www.nytimes.com/books/first/d/danto-art.html?_r=1&oref=slogin